Complete guide

The complete guide for coaches.

Start a debate club, train a team, run practice debates, give useful feedback and get ready for a Regional Round. No debating experience needed.

Coaching advice here is common practice, not rules. The format rules are on the Rules page. Share the debater guide with your students. It covers everything they need to know about the format.

Contents

  1. Starting a debate club
  2. Your first session
  3. Choosing and building a team
  4. A 12-week training programme
  5. Drills library
  6. Running a practice debate
  7. Giving feedback
  8. Coaching impromptu preparation
  9. Coaching each speaker
  10. Competition day
  11. Coaching online
  12. Inclusion and wellbeing
  13. Common problems
  14. Coach checklist

1. Starting a debate club

What you need

Set-up checklist

  1. Get your school's permission, and name a contact person.
  2. Choose a regular time and place. Announce it in assemblies, on notice boards and in class.
  3. Run an open session for anyone interested. Do not require previous experience.
  4. Agree a few rules at the start: listen, challenge ideas and not people, share the time, and keep it confidential.
  5. Set a goal: for example, to enter a Regional Round in January or February. A date focuses the group.
  6. Find a judge or two: a colleague, a former debater or a parent. See the judges page.

Funding and support

2. Your first session (60 minutes)

TimeActivity
0 to 10Welcome. Everyone says their name and one thing they would change about their school. Explain what debate is.
10 to 25Warm-up: "Two corners". Read a light motion ("This house believes that pizza is better than pasta"). Students stand in "agree" or "disagree" corners and give one reason each.
25 to 40Mini-speeches. In pairs, each student gives a 1-minute argument for a side you assign. Their partner says what the reason was.
40 to 55Show the format. Show the speaking order. Show a short video of a debate or read a short script aloud.
55 to 60Homework. Read the motion for next week. Write three reasons for one side.

3. Choosing and building a team

4. A 12-week training programme

One session a week of 60 to 90 minutes. Shorten it to six weeks by doing weeks 1 to 2, 4, 6, 9, 11 and 12, or extend it as needed.

WeekFocusMain activityHomework
1What is debate?First session (above). Introduce motion, Proposition, Opposition.Watch a full debate.
2The formatSpeech order and timing. Practise 2-minute and 4-minute speeches on easy topics. Learn the signals.Prepare a 3-minute speech.
3Building an argumentClaim, reason, example, impact. Turn 5 motions into arguments.Write one argument for each side of a motion.
4Building a caseThe "because" statement. Case division among three speakers. First speaker structure.Write a case for a new motion.
5DefinitionsWhat makes a definition reasonable? Spot bad definitions (squirrels, truisms). Practise defining.Define five motions in one sentence each.
6RebuttalFour ways to answer an argument. Rebuttal drill with recorded or live arguments.Rebut a short article.
7Points of informationOffering and taking POIs. POI game with scores.Prepare three POIs for each side of a motion.
8First practice debateFull debate with 30-minute preparation. Feedback from you or a guest judge.Reflect: one thing to improve.
9Second and third speakersRebuttal-heavy speeches. Third speaker clash practice.Flow a debate video.
10Reply speechesIdentify clashes. Write and deliver 4-minute replies from the same flow.Write a reply for a debate you watched.
11ImpromptuFull debate with 1 hour of preparation, no devices. Follow the preparation plan.None. Rest.
12Mock roundSimulate competition: three judges, ballots, oral adjudication. Review.Complete registration.

5. Drills library

Thinking

Speaking

Rebuttal

Points of information

Team and flow

Knowledge

6. Running a practice debate

  1. Choose the motion. Match the difficulty to the group. Use the motion-writing guide for ideas.
  2. Assign sides and speakers. Rotate each time.
  3. Prepare. Give a limited time: 45 minutes at first, 1 hour for impromptu practice.
  4. Set up the room. Teams face each other. Judge or judges at the side. A timekeeper with signals.
  5. Chair. A student can chair: announce the motion, call speakers, keep order.
  6. Run the debate with real timing: 8 and 4 minutes for older groups, 5 and 3 minutes for beginners.
  7. Judge. Use the judge manual. Ask the debaters to leave while you decide, if you can.
  8. Oral feedback. Give the decision, the reasons and two points for each team.
  9. Debrief. Ask "What would you do differently?" Ask the judge what the debate came down to.

7. Giving feedback

A simple feedback sheet

CriterionStrengthTarget
Content
Style
Strategy
POIs

8. Coaching impromptu preparation

In impromptu debates, teams get the motion shortly before the debate. In the FWW rules, teams have one hour, with only the team members taking part in preparation. They may take in an English dictionary, a bilingual dictionary and one single-volume encyclopaedia or almanac per team, and no phones, computers or other devices. Your host will tell you what applies to your round.

9. Coaching each speaker

RoleStrengths neededTypical problemsCoaching focus
First PropositionClear structure, calmOver-long definition; unclear splitThe 60-second opening; case division
First OppositionQuick thinkingRebuts too little or too muchAccept or challenge; balance rebuttal and own case
Second speakerBoth building and rebuttingForgets to defend first speakerTime split; defending the team
Third speakerListening, weighingLists points; presents new argumentsGrouping into clashes; flow reading
ReplyOverview, fairnessRepeats the speeches; adds new argumentsTwo or three clashes; biased adjudication

10. Competition day

Before

During

After

11. Coaching online

12. Inclusion and wellbeing

13. Common problems

ProblemWhat to try
Students freezeShort speeches. Notes with five words. Give a 30-second silent preparation.
Students read their speechesNotes on a single card. Practise looking up between points.
Arguments are only opinionsAsk "because?" three times. Use the claim, reason, example, impact structure.
Weak rebuttalFour ways to answer. Rebuttal relay.
Team does not agree on the caseWrite the "because" statement on a card. Revisit at every practice.
Nobody takes or offers POIsPOI scoring in every practice. Reward good POIs.
One student dominatesUse time limits. Rotate roles. Give quieter students the first reply.
Students lose motivationGive a goal: a debate against another school, a Regional Round. Celebrate improvement.
Not enough studentsRun two-person practice, or one team and one judge. Invite a neighbouring school.

14. Coach checklist

Ready to enter a team?

Choose a Regional Round and register.

Register a team