Motion-writing advice is common practice, not rules. For motions you can use right away, see the
practice motions page.
Contents
- What a motion is
- Types of motion
- Wording
- Balance and fairness
- Testing a motion
- Choosing the difficulty
- Sensitive topics
- Impromptu and prepared motions
- Fixing a bad motion
- Example motions by topic
- Motion checklist
1. What a motion is
A motion is the sentence the two teams debate. The Proposition argues that it is true or should be done, and the Opposition argues that it is not. In World Schools Style, both teams will interpret it in the same way if it is well written: the rules say that the Proposition must give a reasonable definition, one an ordinary intelligent person would think is the obvious meaning. A good motion makes that easy.
Motions usually begin with "This house" (THW for "would", THBT for "believes that", THS for "supports"). "House" means the world or the debating chamber.
2. Types of motion
| Type | Starts with | Debate is about | Example |
| Change (policy) | THW ... | Whether to take an action. The Proposition proposes a model. | This house would give every student a free school meal. |
| Judgement (value) | THBT ... / THS ... | Whether something is good, true or justified. The Proposition proposes criteria. | This house believes that social media does more harm than good to young people. |
| Principle | THBT ... | A general principle, which the Proposition must show is true in general. | This house believes that the right to protest outweighs the right to public order. |
| Comparison ("rather than") | THW prefer ... to ... | Which of two options is better. | This house would prefer a world with no private cars to a world with private cars. |
| Actor motion | THW, as [actor], ... | What a specific actor should do. Specify the actor carefully. | This house, as a school principal, would ban phones in classrooms. |
- In a change debate the Opposition can argue that the problem is smaller than claimed, that the plan will not solve it, or that there are better solutions.
- In a judgement debate the Opposition can argue that the criteria are wrong, that there are other or additional criteria, or that even on the Proposition's criteria the arguments fail.
3. Wording
- Say one thing. Avoid "and". Two ideas in one motion split the debate.
- Use plain words. Avoid jargon, slang and idioms that may not translate. Teams and judges come from many countries and speak English in different ways.
- Be specific about the action or claim. "This house would improve education" is too vague. "This house would end the use of standardised tests for university admission" can be debated.
- Choose the right level. A general motion lets teams argue general principles. A specific motion needs a specific model. Do not mix levels.
- Avoid absolute words like "all", "always" and "never" unless you want a principle debate. Teams may read them down, but it invites arguments about the words.
- Avoid time and place unless it is the point of the motion. If you need context, say it in the motion or in a short information slide.
- Avoid loaded or biased words. "This house would stop the harmful practice of ..." gives the answer away.
- Avoid double negatives. "This house would not oppose ..." is hard to follow.
- Keep it short. One line, usually under 20 words.
- Use a "this house" form that matches the debate type (see the table).
Information slides
If a motion needs facts that not everyone knows, add a short information slide (two or three sentences) given to both teams. Do not use it to push one side.
4. Balance and fairness
A good motion gives both sides real arguments. A motion that is too easy for one side produces a bad debate and may make a definition fight more likely.
- Is it a truism? "This house believes that education is important" is. Nobody can oppose it.
- Is it a tautology? "This house believes that bad things are bad" is.
- Is it one-sided? "This house would punish criminals" gives the Opposition nothing reasonable to say. Make it specific: "This house would end prison sentences for non-violent offences".
- Does one side need specialist knowledge? Prefer topics that a high school student can argue after an hour.
- Could one side say "it depends"? A motion that cannot be won or lost is too vague.
- Is there a clear burden? It should be obvious what each side must prove.
5. Testing a motion
Before you use a motion, run these tests. They take five minutes.
- The two-list test. Write three good arguments for each side. If you cannot, the motion is unbalanced.
- The ordinary-person test. Show it to someone who is not a debater. Ask "What would this debate be about?" If their answer varies, rewrite it.
- The definition test. Is there only one obvious reading? If a clever team could twist it, tighten it.
- The knowledge test. Could students with the preparation time available (for example one hour, no devices) argue both sides? If not, change the topic or add an information slide.
- The language test. Would a non-native English speaker understand every word?
- The sensitivity test. Could it hurt students in the room? See section 7.
- The clash test. Name the two or three big clashes you expect. If you cannot, the motion may be too narrow.
6. Choosing the difficulty
| Level | Features | Example |
| Beginner | Everyday topics, familiar to students, short, concrete. | This house would start school later in the morning. |
| Intermediate | Social and school-wide issues, some abstract ideas. | This house would ban homework for students under 14. |
| Advanced | Complex ethical, political or economic questions, trade-offs. | This house believes that rich countries should accept more migrants than their citizens want. |
The Regional Round motion is published in advance by the host or set by the host's team. A good progression is to start at beginner level, move to intermediate for the first competition, and use advanced for the Global Final.
7. Sensitive topics
- Debate is a place to discuss hard topics respectfully. Not every topic is right for every group, and some topics will touch students personally.
- Avoid motions that require students to defend hatred or violence against a group.
- Avoid motions that are about specific living people, or that depend on unverified claims.
- Tell students in advance if a motion is sensitive. Allow students to step back from a topic or a side without explanation.
- Think about the local context: law, culture and the safety of students. A topic acceptable in one country may be dangerous in another.
- Remember the code of conduct: attack ideas, never people.
- If in doubt, choose another motion.
8. Impromptu and prepared motions
- Prepared motions are announced in advance. They can be more specialised, because teams can research.
- Impromptu motions are announced shortly before the debate. In the FWW rules, teams get one hour. Choose motions that students can argue from general knowledge and reasoning. Avoid motions that depend on precise statistics or technical expertise.
- Do not announce an impromptu motion in advance. Keep it confidential among organisers and judges until it is released to all teams at the same time.
- Use a motion that has not been debated recently by the participants.
9. Fixing a bad motion
| Problem | Bad version | Better version |
| Truism | This house believes that clean water is important. | This house would make access to clean water a legally enforceable human right. |
| Too vague | This house would improve schools. | This house would pay teachers according to student results. |
| Two ideas | This house would ban fast food and tax sugar. | This house would tax sugary drinks. |
| Loaded | This house would stop the harmful exploitation of young people by social media. | This house would set a minimum age of 16 for social media accounts. |
| Jargon | This house would implement a Pigouvian tax regime. | This house would tax companies for the pollution they cause. |
| Time or place | This house would have banned cars in 1960. | This house would ban private cars from city centres. |
| Absolutes | This house believes that all lying is wrong. | This house believes that it is wrong to lie to protect someone's feelings. |
| Needs expertise | This house would adopt a flat tax of 15 per cent. | This house would tax the rich at higher rates than everyone else. |
10. Example motions by topic
These are suggestions for practice, not official motions of any round.
Education
- This house would replace exams with continuous assessment.
- This house would make a second language compulsory in all schools.
- This house would allow students to choose all of their subjects from age 14.
- This house believes that school uniforms do more good than harm.
Technology and media
- This house would ban phones in schools.
- This house believes that artificial intelligence should be allowed in school homework.
- This house would require social media companies to verify the age of their users.
- This house believes that online anonymity does more harm than good.
Environment
- This house would ban single-use plastics.
- This house would tax meat to reduce its environmental impact.
- This house believes that individual action matters more than government action on climate change.
- This house would limit international flights.
Economy and work
- This house would introduce a four-day working week.
- This house believes that unpaid internships should be banned.
- This house would give every adult a basic income.
- This house believes that developing countries should prioritise economic growth over environmental protection.
Society and ethics
- This house would make voting compulsory.
- This house would lower the voting age to 16.
- This house believes that a free press is more important than national security.
- This house would give schools the right to ban students from wearing religious symbols.
Health and sport
- This house would ban advertising of unhealthy foods to children.
- This house believes that professional athletes are overpaid.
- This house would make physical education compulsory until age 18.
International affairs
- This house would give richer countries a duty to accept refugees in proportion to their wealth.
- This house believes that economic sanctions do more harm than good.
- This house believes that international organisations should have the power to enforce their decisions.
11. Motion checklist
- One idea. Plain words. Under 20 words.
- Not a truism, not a tautology, not one-sided.
- Three good arguments for each side.
- Clear what the Proposition must prove.
- A high school student can argue it without special knowledge.
- Understood by non-native speakers.
- Not hurtful or unsafe for students in the room.
- An information slide, if the facts are needed.