Complete guide

The complete judge manual.

How to judge a World Schools Style debate fairly: what to listen for, how to take notes, how to mark, how to decide, and how to give feedback that helps students improve.

This manual sets out the FWW Global Debate judging standard, including the marking scale. Advice on note-taking and feedback is good practice, not a rule. Your host publishes the ballot and any local changes for your round. Read the debater guide first if you have not judged before.

Contents

  1. The role of the judge
  2. Before the debate
  3. During the debate: taking notes
  4. The three criteria
  5. The marking scale
  6. Assessing the parts of a debate
  7. Deciding the winner
  8. The oral adjudication
  9. Written feedback
  10. Bias and fairness
  11. Judging in a panel
  12. Judging online
  13. Common mistakes
  14. Worked example
  15. Judge checklist

1. The role of the judge

A judge decides which team debated better, and explains why. You are not there to decide which side of the motion is right, or to show how much you know. You are there to listen carefully, assess what the teams actually said and did, and give a clear, fair decision.

How judges are evaluated

Every judge at an FWW Global Debate round is evaluated, so that judging keeps improving and teams can trust it. The evaluation is meant to help you, not to punish you. It takes the form of a short survey sent after the round or competition, not forms filled in during the event.

CriterionWhat it looks at
Preparation and conductOn time, knew the rules and ballot, declared conflicts, respectful to everyone.
ListeningFollowed the whole debate, kept notes, did not rely on their own knowledge or beliefs.
Quality of reasoningDecision explained by the clashes of the debate, with clear reasons.
FairnessMarked within the accepted range, treated both teams equally, allowed for accents and language.
FeedbackOral adjudication short, specific and constructive; useful advice for each team.

Each criterion is rated from 1 (needs significant improvement) to 5 (excellent), with a short comment.

2. Before the debate

3. During the debate: taking notes

The rules do not tell you how to take notes, but good judges keep a record of the debate (often called a "flow"). Without one you will remember the last speech best, and that is unfair to the first speakers.

A simple flow

  1. Draw eight columns, one for each speech, in speaking order.
  2. Write each argument in the column where it was made, in a few words. Use arrows to connect rebuttal to the argument it answers.
  3. Note the examples used, and whether they were explained.
  4. Mark points of information offered, accepted and answered. Note whether the answer helped.
  5. Mark the time of each speech and any overrun.
  6. At the end of each speech, write a short mark (see the scale) and two lines of comment on content, style and strategy.

Time

Main speeches are 8 minutes and replies are 4 minutes. The host provides time signals, normally a signal at 1 minute and at 7 minutes (marking the window for POIs), at the end of the speech, and a warning sign when a speaker overruns. Timing is part of strategy (structure and timing). Your host will tell you whether and how to penalise overrun.

4. The three criteria

The FWW marking standard uses three criteria. Keep them separate. A speaker may be excellent in one and weak in another.

CriterionMain speechReplyQuestion to ask
Content (matter)4020How strong are the arguments and rebuttal? Are they logical, relevant, explained and supported by good examples?
Style (manner)4020How persuasively does the speaker speak? Voice, pace, language, gestures, engagement, use of notes.
Strategy (method)2010Does the speaker understand the real issues of the debate, and is the speech well structured and well timed?

Content

Style

Strategy

Strategy covers two things:

  1. Understanding the issues of the debate. Does the speaker address what really matters, and know what must be proven?
  2. Structure and timing. Is there a clear plan, a sense of priorities, and does the speaker fill (but not exceed) the time?

A speaker who answers the key issues with weak responses should get a poor content mark but a good strategy mark. A speaker who spends time on side issues gets a poor strategy mark, even if each point is good.

Handling of points of information

The way a speaker offers and takes POIs counts in their marks. Look for speakers who accept at least two POIs, answer them directly and briefly, and offer sharp points (about two to four per speech) without barracking. Good POIs reflect content and strategy; the way they are made reflects style.

5. The marking scale

Use the full range of the scale, but stay within the accepted range. Do not be a "harsh" or "generous" marker: use the same standard as the rest of the pool, so that marks are comparable.

Main speeches (out of 100)

StandardOverallStyle /40 and Content /40Strategy /20
Exceptional803216
Excellent76 to 793115 to 16
Extremely good74 to 753015
Very good71 to 732914 to 15
Good702814
Satisfactory67 to 692713 to 14
Competent65 to 662613
Pass61 to 642512 to 13
Improvement needed602412

The accepted range for the content and style sub-marks is 24 to 32 each, and for strategy 12 to 16, giving a main speech range of 60 to 80. This range encourages consistency between judges.

Reply speeches (out of 50)

StandardOverallStyle /20 and Content /20Strategy /10
Exceptional40168
Very good to excellent36 to 39157.5
Good35147
Pass to satisfactory31 to 34136.5
Improvement needed30126

The reply speech accepted range is 30 to 40.

Practical points on marking

6. Assessing the parts of a debate

Definitions

Models and criteria

Burden of proof

Arguments

Rebuttal

Team structure and consistency

Reply speeches

7. Deciding the winner

  1. Mark all the speeches without thinking about the result. Marks are for ranking and feedback.
  2. Go back to your flow. Identify the two to four big questions the debate came down to (the clashes). Examples: "Does a compulsory scheme work?" or "Is the problem as serious as claimed?"
  3. For each clash, decide who won it. Look at who made the better argument, who responded to the other team, and who was still standing at the end.
  4. Weigh the clashes. Which are most important to the motion? A team may win more clashes but lose the most important one.
  5. Check the burden of proof. Did the Proposition show that the motion is true? Did the Opposition show enough doubt or prove an alternative?
  6. Choose the winner. The team that debated better overall wins, in the view of an ordinary intelligent person.
  7. Check for bias. Ask: "Would I decide the same way if the sides were reversed?"

8. The oral adjudication

After the debate, the judges mark independently (see section 11). When the panel has agreed a decision, one judge gives a short oral adjudication on behalf of the panel. The rules say it should be short, explain the result to the audience, set out the key reasons why the winning team won, and comment on significant matters of style and technique. It should be constructive, not negative.

Structure (3 to 5 minutes)

  1. Thank both teams and say briefly what the debate was about.
  2. Announce the result and whether it was unanimous or a majority decision, if the host's rules say so.
  3. The clashes. State the two or three main issues of the debate.
  4. Why the winner won each. Be specific: refer to an argument, a response or an example that was decisive.
  5. What the other team did well, and where they came close.
  6. One or two points of advice for each team. The most useful things they can work on.
  7. Close with a word of encouragement.

9. Written feedback

If the host asks for written feedback on the ballot, keep it short, specific and kind.

Instead ofWrite
"Weak rebuttal.""You answered the cost point but not the main claim about fairness. Pick the strongest argument and answer it first."
"Too fast.""Your pace in the first minute was clear. In the second argument you sped up, and I missed the example. Slow down at key points."
"Good speech.""Your opening clearly set out the case and the three arguments. It made your speech easy to follow."

10. Bias and fairness

11. Judging in a panel

Hosts: see the host guide for how to organise panels.

12. Judging online

13. Common mistakes

14. Worked example

Motion: This house would require all students to do a year of community service after high school.

Debate summary. The Proposition (Team A) argued that service builds responsibility, mixes social groups, and delivers value to communities. The Opposition (Team B) argued that compulsion defeats the purpose and wastes money better spent on voluntary programmes.

ClashTeam A saidTeam B saidWho won, and why
Does compulsion work?Responsibility is learned by doing, not by choosing. Gave a national service example and explained it.Unwilling participants do poor work. Gave an example but did not explain why it applied here.Team A: its example was explained and responded to B's point about unwilling participants in speech 5.
Cost and alternativesCost is small compared with the benefits. Few figures.Voluntary schemes do the job better. Gave a clear comparison.Team B: it explained a better alternative, which A only answered in the reply.
FairnessMixes social groups.Poorer students lose a year of earnings.Team B, narrowly: Team A did not answer this directly.

Decision. Team A won the first clash, which is most central to the motion. Team B won two smaller clashes. The judge weighs them: the central question of the motion is whether compulsory service is worthwhile, and Team A's case on it was stronger and better defended. Team A wins narrowly, but should work on answering the fairness point. Team B should explain its examples more.

This shows the process: the clashes are identified, each is decided, they are weighed, and the decision is tested for bias.

15. Judge checklist

Want to judge a round?

Volunteer judges are welcome.

Become a judge