Ballot, round schedule, motion slip, host checklist, online link sheet, speaker list, flow sheet, point-of-information tracker, results sheet, feedback form, judge evaluation survey questions and chief adjudicator review. Use your browser's print function.
Round Room Judge Motion
Proposition: Opposition:
| Speaker | Name | Style (24 to 32) | Content (24 to 32) | Strategy (12 to 16) | Total (60 to 80) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st Proposition | |||||
| 2nd Proposition | |||||
| 3rd Proposition | |||||
| 1st Opposition | |||||
| 2nd Opposition | |||||
| 3rd Opposition |
| Reply speech | Name | Style (12 to 16) | Content (12 to 16) | Strategy (6 to 8) | Total (30 to 40) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Opposition reply | |||||
| Proposition reply |
Team totals: Proposition Opposition
Judges mark independently and do not compare marks before handing in the ballot. The winner is the team with the majority of the judges' votes. Marks do not decide the winner.
Winner: ☐ Proposition ☐ Opposition Judge signature
Reasons for the decision (the two or three key clashes):
Feedback for teams (one thing done well, one thing to improve):
| Round | Motion released | Preparation until | Debates start | Results due |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||
| 2 | ||||
| 3 | ||||
| 4 | ||||
| Semi-final / final |
| Room | Proposition | Opposition | Judge(s) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||
| 2 | ||||
| 3 | ||||
| 4 | ||||
| 5 | ||||
| 6 |
| ☐ | Date and venue confirmed. Enough rooms for every debate, plus preparation space and a tab room |
| ☐ | Teams registered and school contacts collected |
| ☐ | Judges recruited, with no conflicts. Judge guide sent |
| ☐ | Chief adjudicator and tab director named |
| ☐ | Motions prepared and kept confidential |
| ☐ | Ballots, schedule, room signs and motion slips printed |
| ☐ | Timers, pens and signs in every room |
| ☐ | Accessibility needs checked and a first-aid contact identified |
| ☐ | Photograph consent arranged |
| ☐ | Results recorded and sent to FWW Global Debate when asked |
Round Date Platform Main hall link
| Room | Link | Passcode | Proposition | Opposition | Monitor | Judges |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 | ||||||
| 3 | ||||||
| 4 | ||||||
| 5 | ||||||
| 6 |
Send each team only its own preparation room and debate room links. Keep the tab room link private.
Round Room Side: ☐ Proposition ☐ Opposition
School / team
Give this list to the chair before the debate starts. Only these three speakers may speak. A reply is given by the first or second speaker.
| Order | Speaker name | Grade / school year |
|---|---|---|
| 1st speaker | ||
| 2nd speaker | ||
| 3rd speaker | ||
| Reply speaker (1st or 2nd) |
Reserves (not speaking in this debate):
Coach / contact Phone
Motion
Write each argument in the column of the speech where it was made. Draw arrows from rebuttal to the argument it answers. Note examples, points of information and the main clashes.
| 1st Prop | 1st Opp | 2nd Prop | 2nd Opp | 3rd Prop | 3rd Opp | Opp reply | Prop reply |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
The two or three main clashes:
For coaches and judges. Tick each point of information offered, accepted and answered well. Points of information may be offered between the first and seventh minute of a main speech, last up to 15 seconds, and a speaker should accept at least two.
| Speech | Offered by the other team | Accepted | Answer was clear and direct | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st Proposition | ||||
| 1st Opposition | ||||
| 2nd Proposition | ||||
| 2nd Opposition | ||||
| 3rd Proposition | ||||
| 3rd Opposition |
Round Date
| Room | Proposition | Opposition | Judges' votes for Prop | Judges' votes for Opp | Winner | Checked by |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ranking after the preliminary rounds: number of wins, then number of judges' votes in favour, then average judges' scores (the FWW order). Publish your tie-break rules before the round. Keep every paper ballot until the results are confirmed.
Keep it short, specific and constructive. Say who won, then why.
| 1. Thank both teams. The motion in one line | |
|---|---|
| 2. The result and whether unanimous or by majority | |
| 3. The two or three main clashes | |
| 4. Why the winner won each clash | |
| 5. What the other team did well | |
| 6. One piece of advice for each team |
Round Your role: ☐ Debater ☐ Coach ☐ Judge ☐ Volunteer
| Question | 1 (poor) | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 (excellent) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information before the day was clear | |||||
| The schedule was kept | |||||
| The motions were fair and well chosen | |||||
| Judging was fair and the reasons were clear | |||||
| I felt safe and respected | |||||
| The venue or platform worked well |
What went best?
What should change?
These are the questions of the online judge evaluation survey, which debaters and coaches receive by email after the round or competition has finished. It is not filled in during the event. Rate each criterion from 1 (needs significant improvement) to 5 (excellent). Your answers are used only to help judges improve and are never published with your name.
Round Room Judge evaluated Your role: ☐ Debater ☐ Coach
| Criterion | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Comment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Preparation and conduct: on time, respectful, knew the rules | ||||||
| Listening: followed the whole debate | ||||||
| Quality of reasoning: the decision was clearly explained | ||||||
| Fairness: treated both teams equally | ||||||
| Feedback: constructive and useful |
One thing the judge did well:
One thing the judge could improve:
Round Date
| Room | Judge | Chief adjudicator rating (1-5) | Chief adjudicator notes | Next round: ☐ Chair ☐ Standard ☐ Needs support |
|---|---|---|---|---|