This guide explains the FWW Global Debate format and gives coaching advice. The rules of your round are on the
Rules page, and your host publishes any local details, including changes for online debates. Advice on technique is coaching practice, not rules.
Contents
- The format at a glance
- Types of motion
- Definitions and what the debate is about
- Building a case
- How to build one argument
- The job of each speaker
- Rebuttal
- Points of information
- The reply speech
- How you are judged
- Speaking style
- Preparation
- How to improve
- Common mistakes
- Debating online
World Schools Style is a team debate between two teams, Proposition (for the motion) and Opposition (against it). A team has three speakers in each debate. Teams may register 3 to 5 debaters, and the three who speak can change from one debate to the next. Each speaker gives one main speech of 8 minutes. After the six main speeches, each team gives a 4-minute reply speech.
| Order | Speech | Length | Points of information |
| 1 | First Proposition | 8 min | Allowed, minutes 1 to 7 |
| 2 | First Opposition | 8 min | Allowed, minutes 1 to 7 |
| 3 | Second Proposition | 8 min | Allowed, minutes 1 to 7 |
| 4 | Second Opposition | 8 min | Allowed, minutes 1 to 7 |
| 5 | Third Proposition | 8 min | Allowed, minutes 1 to 7 |
| 6 | Third Opposition | 8 min | Allowed, minutes 1 to 7 |
| 7 | Opposition Reply | 4 min | Not allowed |
| 8 | Proposition Reply | 4 min | Not allowed |
- Before the debate, each team gives the chair the names of its three speakers and the order they will speak in.
- Only those three speakers may speak. Each speaks once in the main speeches.
- The reply speech is given by the first or second speaker of the team. It cannot be the third speaker.
- During the debate, speakers may not communicate with their coach, with team members who are not speaking in that debate, or with people in the audience. The only exception is a discreet time signal.
2. Types of motion
A motion is the sentence the two teams argue about. In the World Schools format there are two kinds of debate.
- Prepared motion. The motion is announced in advance, so you can research and practise it.
- Impromptu motion. The motion is announced shortly before the debate. In the FWW rules, teams then have one hour to prepare, with no phones, computers or printed material, except an English dictionary, a bilingual dictionary and one single-volume encyclopaedia or almanac per team. Ask your host how your round works.
Motions usually ask one of two questions. Knowing which one you have tells you what to prove.
| Kind | Looks like | What the Proposition must show |
| Change (policy) debate | "This house would ban homework." | There is a problem, your plan (the model) solves it, and it is better than the alternatives. |
| Judgement (value) debate | "This house believes that social media does more harm than good." | A standard (criteria) for judging the subject, and that the subject passes or fails it. |
| Principle debate | "This house believes that economic growth is more important than protecting the environment." | The principle holds true in general, not just in one example. |
Motions are written with "This house" (THW, THBT, THS and so on). "House" simply means the world, or the debating chamber.
3. Definitions and what the debate is about
The first Proposition speaker starts by defining the motion: saying what the debate is about. The rules ask for a reasonable definition: one an ordinary intelligent person would accept as what the motion obviously means.
- Match the level of the motion. If the motion is general, define it generally. Do not shrink a general motion to a single case.
- Do not make the debate impossible for the other side. Avoid truisms ("Murder is bad"), tautologies (true by definition), and definitions that put the other team in an unwinnable position.
- Do not "squirrel". Squirrelling means twisting the motion so you can run an argument you prepared earlier. This is illegitimate.
- Do not set time or place (for example, "in 1950" or "in one country") unless the motion says so.
- Use ordinary meanings. Avoid obscure dictionary meanings.
- Parameters and models must be reasonable too. If you propose a plan or a standard, it must be one an ordinary person would accept as fair and workable.
If you are Opposition and the definition is unreasonable
The first Opposition speaker has four choices:
- Accept it and debate on its merits. This is the best choice in most debates.
- Challenge it and offer a better definition.
- Broaden the debate back to what the words of the motion actually mean.
- "Even if": challenge it, and also argue that even if the definition were reasonable, the Proposition's case is wrong.
A definition challenge is rare and tends to make the debate messy. Under the FWW rules the first Opposition may challenge the definition only if it is unreasonable, and if it does, it must propose a new definition that is itself reasonable. If the first Opposition speaker does not challenge, the Opposition is taken to have accepted the definition and may not challenge it later, unless the Proposition significantly alters it in later speeches. Never spend the whole debate arguing about words rather than the issue.
4. Building a case
Each team presents one case (also called a team line or team theme). The case is the central reason why your side is right. A good test is the "because" statement: "We are right because ..." If you cannot finish that sentence in one line, you do not yet have a case.
The case is supported by arguments (usually two or three), and each argument is supported by examples. The three speakers share the work: the first speaker usually presents the case and one or two arguments, the second speaker presents further arguments and rebuts, and the third speaker mainly rebuts.
- Put the most important arguments first. Speaker one and two present the core of the case.
- Write the case down. All three speakers should have the same sentence in front of them, and every speech should return to it.
- A narrow case is fine. A narrow case can be legitimate, as long as it fairly answers the motion. A narrow definition is not.
- Announce the split. In the first speech, say which speaker will present which argument. This is called the case division or "team split". If a third speaker is going to present a small part of the case, the first speaker must announce it.
Example: change debate
Motion: This house would require all students to do a year of community service after high school.
Proposition case: "We should require it because it builds responsibility, reduces inequality of experience, and benefits communities, at a cost young people can afford." Model: 11 months, near home, with allowances; exemptions for illness and care duties. Arguments: (1) It builds skills and character. (2) It brings together young people from different backgrounds. (3) It delivers real services to communities.
Opposition case: "A compulsory scheme takes away choice and delivers poor quality service, and voluntary schemes do the job better." Arguments: (1) Compulsion defeats the purpose of service. (2) Unwilling participants deliver poor work. (3) The money is better spent on voluntary programmes.
5. How to build one argument
An argument is not an opinion or a list of facts. It is a chain of reasoning that leads the judge from your case to a conclusion. Use four steps:
- Claim. The point, in one clear sentence. "Compulsory service builds responsibility."
- Reason (the "because"). Why it is true. "Because people learn responsibility when others depend on them, and a placement creates that dependence."
- Example. Evidence that shows it. Use well-known events, real programmes, history, or a realistic situation. Explain the example, not just name it.
- Impact. Why the judge should care, and how it helps your side win the motion.
The most common weakness is jumping from the case straight to examples. The missing middle is the reasoning. Always explain why the example proves your point, and what it shows about the general case.
- Prove principles logically. When the motion states a general principle, a list of examples is not enough. Show why it is true in general.
- Use few examples, fully explained. One well-developed example beats five names.
- Use well-known examples. The judge may not know a specialist case. Explain who, what, when, and why it matters.
- Avoid personal anecdotes. They cannot be checked, and they are not evidence about a whole society.
- Do not rely on statistics you cannot explain. Judges are told not to use their own specialist knowledge to decide whether an argument is good, so you must make the argument compelling on the page. A made-up number is worse than no number.
6. The job of each speaker
First Proposition
- Greet the chair and the audience briefly, then define the motion and set out any model or criteria.
- Present the team case and the case division.
- Present the first part of the case (usually one or two arguments).
- No rebuttal is possible, because nobody has spoken yet.
First Opposition
- Accept or challenge the definition.
- Present the Opposition case and the case division.
- Rebut the first Proposition speaker. Typically the first part of the speech.
- Present the first part of the Opposition case.
Second speakers
- Defend the definition if it is still in dispute.
- Rebut the other team's case: about 2 to 3 minutes for the Proposition and 3 to 4 minutes for the Opposition (the Opposition has more to answer). Defend your own first speaker's arguments against the attack they received.
- Present new arguments for the rest of the speech, finishing the case that the first speaker announced.
Third speakers
- The main job is to respond to the other team: to deal with the definition if it is still an issue and to answer the opposing case in detail.
- Also defend your team against the rebuttal it has received.
- May present a small part of the team's case (typically 1 to 2 minutes), but only if the first speaker announced it. The emphasis must stay on rebuttal.
- The best third speakers do not give a list of rebuttals. They group the debate into the two or three big questions and explain why their side wins each one.
Reply speakers
See section 9.
| Speaker | New argument? | Rebuttal | Main aim |
| 1st | Yes (main part of the case) | 1st Opposition only | Set the frame: definition, case, split |
| 2nd | Yes | Yes, 2 to 4 minutes | Finish the case and defend it |
| 3rd | Only a small part if announced | Yes, most of the speech | Win the clashes |
| Reply | No new argument; a new example for an existing argument is allowed | Summary only | Explain why your side won |
7. Rebuttal
Rebuttal means answering the other team's arguments. As the debate goes on, speakers spend less time on new material and more on answering what was said. Weak rebuttal is the most common reason a good case loses.
Four ways to answer an argument
- It is not true. The reasoning is flawed or the example does not show what they claim.
- It is true but does not matter. Even if correct, it is small, rare, or beside the point of the motion.
- It helps us, not you. The argument actually supports our side.
- Even if it is true, we outweigh it. Our argument is more important.
The rebuttal method: "Their point, our response, why it matters"
- Say what they said. Briefly and fairly. Naming the argument shows the judge you are answering the right thing.
- Respond. Give your reason, with an example if you can.
- Say why it matters. Show the judge what this does to their case.
Other points
- Answer the strongest points, not the easiest. Judges notice what was left unanswered.
- Rebut as a team. Do not repeat a point your partner already answered. Build on it.
- Group points. Answer three related claims with one response.
- Keep the other team's side in view. In a change debate, the Opposition can say that the problem is smaller than claimed, that the plan will not solve it, or that there is a better solution. In a judgement debate, the Opposition can say that the criteria are not right, that there are other or additional criteria, or that the Proposition's arguments fail even on its own criteria.
- A weak argument is a weak argument. Judges are asked to mark an argument down if it is weak, even if the other team never pointed it out. But do not count on it.
8. Points of information
A point of information (POI) is a short question or comment offered by a member of the opposing team during a main speech. It is one of the things that makes World Schools debate lively.
The rules
- POIs may be offered only between the first and seventh minute of an 8-minute speech. A signal (often a clap or a soft tap on the table) marks the start and end of this window. The first and last minutes are protected.
- A POI is short, no more than 15 seconds. It may be a question or a short point.
- You offer a POI by standing and saying "point of information" or "on that point". You do not need to address the chair.
- The speaker may accept, or decline, or ask you to wait until the end of the sentence. They have an absolute right to refuse, but as a general rule they should accept at least two in a speech.
- Do not interrupt so often that you are "barracking". As a general rule, nobody on a team should offer another POI within 20 seconds of the last one offered by their team.
- The FWW rules say a speaker should offer POIs both before and after giving their own speech, so stay engaged when you are not speaking.
- No POIs are allowed in reply speeches.
Offering POIs well
- Offer two to four in each speech. Too few looks passive; too many looks rude.
- Make them sharp and specific: a question that exposes a gap, an example that contradicts them, or a point that connects to your own case.
- Prepare a few in advance based on the case you expect. Keep a list of the other team's weak spots.
- Sit down when declined. Do not argue. Do not read from a page.
- The speaker's marks include how well they handle POIs, and speakers on the other team are credited for good ones.
Taking POIs well
- Accept at least two per speech, ideally on good occasions: after you have finished a point, not in the middle of a sentence.
- Listen to the whole question. Answer directly, briefly, and with confidence. Then go back to your speech.
- Do not accept a POI at the very moment you are explaining your most important point.
- A speaker who refuses everything looks afraid. A speaker who accepts every offer loses control of the speech.
9. The reply speech
The reply is a 4-minute summary of the whole debate, given by one team member (the first or second speaker) after the main speeches. The opposition reply goes first and the proposition reply goes last. No POIs are allowed.
- Do not add a new part of the case. You may use a new example to illustrate an argument that was already made, but you may not introduce a new argument.
- Do not go through the debate speech by speech. Boil it down to two or three clashes: the key disagreements. For each, say what each side argued and why yours won.
- Think of it as a biased adjudication. You are explaining to the judges why your side won, in the way an adjudicator would, but from your perspective.
- Be fair. If you misrepresent the other team's argument, the judge will notice.
- Finish with a clear closing line that goes back to the motion.
Sample structure for a 4-minute reply
| Time | What to do |
| 0:00 to 0:20 | Say what the debate was about and your side's central claim. |
| 0:20 to 1:30 | First clash: what they said, what we said, why we win. |
| 1:30 to 2:40 | Second clash, in the same way. |
| 2:40 to 3:30 | Third clash, or explain why the strongest opposing point does not matter. |
| 3:30 to 4:00 | Close: one sentence that answers the motion. |
10. How you are judged
Every speech is marked out of 100 (main speech) or 50 (reply) using three criteria. This follows the FWW marking standard.
| Criterion | Main speech | Reply speech | What it rewards |
| Content | /40 | /20 | The strength of the arguments and rebuttal, regardless of delivery |
| Style | /40 | /20 | How persuasively you speak: voice, gesture, language, engagement |
| Strategy | /20 | /10 | Understanding the issues of the debate; structure and timing |
Typical marks fall in a narrow range: a main speech between 60 and 80 (with 80 being exceptional), and a reply between 30 and 40.
| Standard | Main speech (/100) | Reply speech (/50) |
| Exceptional | 80 | 40 |
| Excellent | 76 to 79 | 36 to 39 (very good to excellent) |
| Extremely good | 74 to 75 | |
| Very good | 71 to 73 | |
| Good | 70 | 35 |
| Satisfactory | 67 to 69 | 31 to 34 (pass to satisfactory) |
| Competent | 65 to 66 | |
| Pass | 61 to 64 | |
| Improvement needed | 60 | 30 |
- The winner is decided by the judges' votes. A debate is won by the team that gets the majority of the judges' votes. Marks are not added up to pick the winner; they are used to rank speakers and teams.
- Judges are asked to ignore their own beliefs and specialist knowledge, to mark non-native English speakers as if they were native speakers, and to allow for different accents and styles.
- If a speaker cannot give their speech after the debate has begun, another speaker of the same team who was announced at the start may speak in their place. That speech is scored like any other, but its marks do not count towards individual speaker rankings, and a team that does this more than once in the preliminary rounds cannot break.
- An argument is judged on how persuasive it is for an ordinary, intelligent listener. The Proposition does not have to prove its case beyond doubt, but it has to be convincing as a general proposition. The Opposition must create more than a reasonable doubt about it.
A speaker who answers the key issues of the debate with weak answers should get a low content mark but a good strategy mark. A speaker who answers the wrong issues, however eloquently, will get a low strategy mark.
11. Speaking style
Style is not about acting or having a perfect accent. It is how well you carry the judge with you.
- Pace. Speak clearly at a pace that lets the listener think. Rushing is the most common problem. Pause before key points.
- Voice. Vary pitch and volume. A flat voice makes strong arguments sound weak.
- Notes. Use short notes (an outline and key words). Do not read your speech. Look at the judges and the other team.
- Signposting. Say where you are: "My first argument ...", "Moving to rebuttal ...". It helps the judge follow the structure and write it down.
- Language. Use simple, exact words. Avoid long sentences and jargon. Explain any technical term.
- Body. Stand still and use gestures to emphasise, not to fidget. Keep eye contact.
- Tone. Be firm but respectful. Attack arguments, never people.
- Humour. Use only when natural, and never at someone's expense.
Debaters whose first language is not English are judged as if they were native speakers, and judges allow for accents. Clarity matters more than vocabulary.
12. Preparation
In one hour (impromptu motions)
| Minutes | Task |
| 0 to 5 | Read the motion slowly. Ask: what would an ordinary intelligent person expect this debate to be about? Agree a definition and, if needed, a model or criteria. Check each key word. |
| 5 to 15 | Brainstorm freely. All team members contribute (up to five can prepare). List arguments, examples, and what the other team will say. |
| 15 to 25 | Choose the two or three best arguments. Write the team case in a "because" sentence. Decide who speaks in what order and who gives the reply. |
| 25 to 45 | Each speaker outlines their own speech. The others add examples and anticipated rebuttals. Third speakers prepare a list of likely attacks and responses. |
| 45 to 55 | Rehearse the opening and the team split. Prepare POIs to offer and likely POIs to take. |
| 55 to 60 | Check the plan. Make sure everyone knows the case, the split, and their role. |
For prepared motions
- Research both sides. You may be assigned either one.
- Build a bank of two or three well-explained examples for each argument.
- Practise rebuttal: write the five strongest arguments for the other side and prepare responses.
- Do not write out your speech. Memorised speeches sound stiff and are hard to adapt.
During the debate
- Flow the debate. Take notes in columns: one for each team's arguments, so you can see what has been answered.
- Keep a list of POIs to offer when the other team makes a weak point.
- The three speakers in the debate may communicate with each other, quietly and without disturbing the speaker. They may not communicate with the coach, with other team members who are not speaking, or with the audience.
- Watch the time. Know your signals.
13. How to improve
Skills to practise
| Skill | Drill |
| Building arguments | Take a motion. In 5 minutes, write three arguments with claim, reason, example, impact. Present one in 2 minutes. |
| Rebuttal | Listen to a recorded 3-minute argument. Respond in 2 minutes using the four types of answer. |
| POIs | Deliver a 4-minute speech while a partner offers POIs. Accept two. Switch roles. |
| Reply speeches | Watch a debate. Write a 4-minute reply for each side from the notes alone. |
| Thinking quickly | Draw a motion. 15 minutes to prepare a 4-minute speech. Get feedback. |
| Delivery | Record yourself. Watch for pace, filler words, and eye contact. |
| Listening | Flow a debate. Compare your flow with a partner's. |
| Knowledge | Read quality news and analysis every day, across politics, economics, science, society and ethics. |
- Watch good debates. Notice how top speakers structure speeches, handle POIs, and make replies.
- Ask for feedback. Ask judges for one thing to keep and one to change.
- Judge sometimes. Judging teaches you what makes arguments persuasive.
- Coaches: see the Complete guide for coaches.
14. Common mistakes
- Debating definitions, not the motion. Only challenge if truly necessary.
- Squirrelling. Twisting the motion to fit an argument you prepared.
- Examples without reasoning. A list of events does not prove a principle.
- Speaking too fast. Judges reward clarity, not speed.
- Under-using or over-using time. Fill the time; do not run over.
- Ignoring the other team. Answer what they actually said.
- Third speaker presents a new case. Their job is rebuttal; a new part of the case must be announced by the first speaker.
- Reply speech with new arguments. Not allowed. Summarise and weigh.
- Never taking POIs. It looks like you are afraid.
- Repeating the first speaker. Each speaker should add something.
- Team inconsistency. Speakers who contradict each other. Keep the team case in view.
- Personal attacks. Attack ideas, never people.
15. Debating online
- Test your camera, microphone and connection before the debate. Join early.
- Use a headset and a quiet place. Look at the camera when speaking.
- Keep your video on, and mute when not speaking.
- POIs online: use the host's method (often the chat, a raised hand, or an unmuted brief interruption). Follow the host's instructions.
- Speak a little more slowly than usual, and pause after key points, because there can be a delay.
- Keep notes on paper so you do not look away from the screen.
- Team communication during the debate follows the same rules. Do not use a second device to chat with your teammates unless the host allows it.