Complete guide

The complete guide for debaters.

Everything a high school student needs to take part in a World Schools Style debate: the format, each speaker's job, how to build a case, how to rebut, how to prepare, and how to improve.

This guide explains the FWW Global Debate format and gives coaching advice. The rules of your round are on the Rules page, and your host publishes any local details, including changes for online debates. Advice on technique is coaching practice, not rules.

Contents

  1. The format at a glance
  2. Types of motion
  3. Definitions and what the debate is about
  4. Building a case
  5. How to build one argument
  6. The job of each speaker
  7. Rebuttal
  8. Points of information
  9. The reply speech
  10. How you are judged
  11. Speaking style
  12. Preparation
  13. How to improve
  14. Common mistakes
  15. Debating online

1. The format at a glance

World Schools Style is a team debate between two teams, Proposition (for the motion) and Opposition (against it). A team has three speakers in each debate. Teams may register 3 to 5 debaters, and the three who speak can change from one debate to the next. Each speaker gives one main speech of 8 minutes. After the six main speeches, each team gives a 4-minute reply speech.

OrderSpeechLengthPoints of information
1First Proposition8 minAllowed, minutes 1 to 7
2First Opposition8 minAllowed, minutes 1 to 7
3Second Proposition8 minAllowed, minutes 1 to 7
4Second Opposition8 minAllowed, minutes 1 to 7
5Third Proposition8 minAllowed, minutes 1 to 7
6Third Opposition8 minAllowed, minutes 1 to 7
7Opposition Reply4 minNot allowed
8Proposition Reply4 minNot allowed

2. Types of motion

A motion is the sentence the two teams argue about. In the World Schools format there are two kinds of debate.

Motions usually ask one of two questions. Knowing which one you have tells you what to prove.

KindLooks likeWhat the Proposition must show
Change (policy) debate"This house would ban homework."There is a problem, your plan (the model) solves it, and it is better than the alternatives.
Judgement (value) debate"This house believes that social media does more harm than good."A standard (criteria) for judging the subject, and that the subject passes or fails it.
Principle debate"This house believes that economic growth is more important than protecting the environment."The principle holds true in general, not just in one example.

Motions are written with "This house" (THW, THBT, THS and so on). "House" simply means the world, or the debating chamber.

3. Definitions and what the debate is about

The first Proposition speaker starts by defining the motion: saying what the debate is about. The rules ask for a reasonable definition: one an ordinary intelligent person would accept as what the motion obviously means.

If you are Opposition and the definition is unreasonable

The first Opposition speaker has four choices:

  1. Accept it and debate on its merits. This is the best choice in most debates.
  2. Challenge it and offer a better definition.
  3. Broaden the debate back to what the words of the motion actually mean.
  4. "Even if": challenge it, and also argue that even if the definition were reasonable, the Proposition's case is wrong.

A definition challenge is rare and tends to make the debate messy. Under the FWW rules the first Opposition may challenge the definition only if it is unreasonable, and if it does, it must propose a new definition that is itself reasonable. If the first Opposition speaker does not challenge, the Opposition is taken to have accepted the definition and may not challenge it later, unless the Proposition significantly alters it in later speeches. Never spend the whole debate arguing about words rather than the issue.

4. Building a case

Each team presents one case (also called a team line or team theme). The case is the central reason why your side is right. A good test is the "because" statement: "We are right because ..." If you cannot finish that sentence in one line, you do not yet have a case.

The case is supported by arguments (usually two or three), and each argument is supported by examples. The three speakers share the work: the first speaker usually presents the case and one or two arguments, the second speaker presents further arguments and rebuts, and the third speaker mainly rebuts.

Example: change debate

Motion: This house would require all students to do a year of community service after high school.

Proposition case: "We should require it because it builds responsibility, reduces inequality of experience, and benefits communities, at a cost young people can afford." Model: 11 months, near home, with allowances; exemptions for illness and care duties. Arguments: (1) It builds skills and character. (2) It brings together young people from different backgrounds. (3) It delivers real services to communities.

Opposition case: "A compulsory scheme takes away choice and delivers poor quality service, and voluntary schemes do the job better." Arguments: (1) Compulsion defeats the purpose of service. (2) Unwilling participants deliver poor work. (3) The money is better spent on voluntary programmes.

5. How to build one argument

An argument is not an opinion or a list of facts. It is a chain of reasoning that leads the judge from your case to a conclusion. Use four steps:

  1. Claim. The point, in one clear sentence. "Compulsory service builds responsibility."
  2. Reason (the "because"). Why it is true. "Because people learn responsibility when others depend on them, and a placement creates that dependence."
  3. Example. Evidence that shows it. Use well-known events, real programmes, history, or a realistic situation. Explain the example, not just name it.
  4. Impact. Why the judge should care, and how it helps your side win the motion.

The most common weakness is jumping from the case straight to examples. The missing middle is the reasoning. Always explain why the example proves your point, and what it shows about the general case.

6. The job of each speaker

First Proposition

First Opposition

Second speakers

Third speakers

Reply speakers

See section 9.

SpeakerNew argument?RebuttalMain aim
1stYes (main part of the case)1st Opposition onlySet the frame: definition, case, split
2ndYesYes, 2 to 4 minutesFinish the case and defend it
3rdOnly a small part if announcedYes, most of the speechWin the clashes
ReplyNo new argument; a new example for an existing argument is allowedSummary onlyExplain why your side won

7. Rebuttal

Rebuttal means answering the other team's arguments. As the debate goes on, speakers spend less time on new material and more on answering what was said. Weak rebuttal is the most common reason a good case loses.

Four ways to answer an argument

  1. It is not true. The reasoning is flawed or the example does not show what they claim.
  2. It is true but does not matter. Even if correct, it is small, rare, or beside the point of the motion.
  3. It helps us, not you. The argument actually supports our side.
  4. Even if it is true, we outweigh it. Our argument is more important.

The rebuttal method: "Their point, our response, why it matters"

Other points

8. Points of information

A point of information (POI) is a short question or comment offered by a member of the opposing team during a main speech. It is one of the things that makes World Schools debate lively.

The rules

Offering POIs well

Taking POIs well

9. The reply speech

The reply is a 4-minute summary of the whole debate, given by one team member (the first or second speaker) after the main speeches. The opposition reply goes first and the proposition reply goes last. No POIs are allowed.

Sample structure for a 4-minute reply

TimeWhat to do
0:00 to 0:20Say what the debate was about and your side's central claim.
0:20 to 1:30First clash: what they said, what we said, why we win.
1:30 to 2:40Second clash, in the same way.
2:40 to 3:30Third clash, or explain why the strongest opposing point does not matter.
3:30 to 4:00Close: one sentence that answers the motion.

10. How you are judged

Every speech is marked out of 100 (main speech) or 50 (reply) using three criteria. This follows the FWW marking standard.

CriterionMain speechReply speechWhat it rewards
Content/40/20The strength of the arguments and rebuttal, regardless of delivery
Style/40/20How persuasively you speak: voice, gesture, language, engagement
Strategy/20/10Understanding the issues of the debate; structure and timing

Typical marks fall in a narrow range: a main speech between 60 and 80 (with 80 being exceptional), and a reply between 30 and 40.

StandardMain speech (/100)Reply speech (/50)
Exceptional8040
Excellent76 to 7936 to 39 (very good to excellent)
Extremely good74 to 75
Very good71 to 73
Good7035
Satisfactory67 to 6931 to 34 (pass to satisfactory)
Competent65 to 66
Pass61 to 64
Improvement needed6030

A speaker who answers the key issues of the debate with weak answers should get a low content mark but a good strategy mark. A speaker who answers the wrong issues, however eloquently, will get a low strategy mark.

11. Speaking style

Style is not about acting or having a perfect accent. It is how well you carry the judge with you.

Debaters whose first language is not English are judged as if they were native speakers, and judges allow for accents. Clarity matters more than vocabulary.

12. Preparation

In one hour (impromptu motions)

MinutesTask
0 to 5Read the motion slowly. Ask: what would an ordinary intelligent person expect this debate to be about? Agree a definition and, if needed, a model or criteria. Check each key word.
5 to 15Brainstorm freely. All team members contribute (up to five can prepare). List arguments, examples, and what the other team will say.
15 to 25Choose the two or three best arguments. Write the team case in a "because" sentence. Decide who speaks in what order and who gives the reply.
25 to 45Each speaker outlines their own speech. The others add examples and anticipated rebuttals. Third speakers prepare a list of likely attacks and responses.
45 to 55Rehearse the opening and the team split. Prepare POIs to offer and likely POIs to take.
55 to 60Check the plan. Make sure everyone knows the case, the split, and their role.

For prepared motions

During the debate

13. How to improve

Skills to practise

SkillDrill
Building argumentsTake a motion. In 5 minutes, write three arguments with claim, reason, example, impact. Present one in 2 minutes.
RebuttalListen to a recorded 3-minute argument. Respond in 2 minutes using the four types of answer.
POIsDeliver a 4-minute speech while a partner offers POIs. Accept two. Switch roles.
Reply speechesWatch a debate. Write a 4-minute reply for each side from the notes alone.
Thinking quicklyDraw a motion. 15 minutes to prepare a 4-minute speech. Get feedback.
DeliveryRecord yourself. Watch for pace, filler words, and eye contact.
ListeningFlow a debate. Compare your flow with a partner's.
KnowledgeRead quality news and analysis every day, across politics, economics, science, society and ethics.

14. Common mistakes

15. Debating online

Ready to compete?

Register your team for a Regional Round.

Register a team